Trade between countries in the globalized world is inevitable and Malaysia also depends a lot on it. In 2006, the total number of Malaysian exports and imports was worth 26.7 billions US dollars. The main trade partner of Malaysia during the early age of its independence was Britain, but now the trade has extended to other countries, including the United States, Singapore, Japan, China and Hong Kong. In the future, trade with China is predicted to rise as the country is growing to become the world’s superpower in economy. Many Malaysians believe that China competes with Malaysia’s economy as it has more attractions for investors and the Chinese products are cheaper compared to domestic products. After doing research on this topic, I found that China actually does not pose any threat to the Malaysian economy. This statement is based on four reasons. First, trade with China has given local investors the chance to set up their business in China. Next, Malaysia can also export its high-skilled workers and natural resource products to meet the demand in China. Third, cheaper products that come from China will also give Malaysian consumers advantage and at the same time encourage local industrial players to be competitive. And the last reason is the strategic location of Malaysia on the route of China and the west, making it a potential place to set up a stop center for trade and products exchange.
The first reason why Malaysia should continue having extensive trade with China is that it will create more chances for Malaysian investors to go abroad particularly to China and open business there. FTA (Free Trade Area) agreements that have been signed by leaders in most east Asian countries have broken the economic barriers between them. This is because the FTA agreements generally will require countries to abolish the quotas, tariffs and taxes that are normally used to protect their local industry. With this abolishment, it is now easier for Malaysian investors to step to other countries and extend their business. According to Dr Hummels, an economics professor at Krannert School, China is still the best place since it has a constant supply of natural resources and a high population, which means a big market for investors. Moreover, Dr Hummels added that the economic zones equipped with the best infrastructure along the Chinese coast and the country’s liberalized economic policies are the other reasons that make China one of the preferable places to start a business. Malaysian investors should grab the opportunities in China to extend their business abroad as there are not so many countries in the world who have all the advantages mentioned earlier. Moreover, advice from the Prime Minister of Malaysia, Datuk Seri Abdullah Badawi that Malaysians should be brave and go abroad must be taken seriously by them.
Besides giving a chance for Malaysian investors to invest in China, another reason why trade with China is opportunity for Malaysia is that Malaysia can export its high-skilled labor and natural resources to China. Micheal Elliot, in his article from Time magazine- “The Chinese Century.” states that in order the meet the outsourcing demand for natural resources especially oil, the fast-growing country has started exploring African continent (33). China wants to ensure that it gets a constant supply of oil from the continent. However, it is costly for China to transport the oil from the African continent. Therefore, Malaysia can help China to meet its demand for oil since Malaysia is one of the nearest oil suppliers to China and it will certainly lower the transportation cost. High-skilled labor is another field that Malaysia can take advantage of. The Malaysian educational system produces thousands of unemployed graduates every year. Most of the students who graduated from professional courses are unemployed because there is a lack of employment available in Malaysia itself. Meanwhile, according to Dr. Hummels, China is transforming from a labor-intensive industry into a high technology industry that requires a lot of high-skilled and knowledgeable labor, which Chinese tertiary education might be unable to meet for the time being. Malaysian graduates can take advantage of working in China and not just depend on the employment available in their home country.
Trade with China is not only beneficial for the Malaysian investors and high-skilled labors mentioned earlier. It also gives an advantage to consumers in Malaysia to get cheaper Chinese goods that invade Malaysia, which is my third reason why I say trade with China is positive for Malaysia. The goods are varied, including clothes, silverware, decors, rice, citrus fruits and some electronic gadgets. Even though this scenario might not last forever, it certainly helps low–income families in Malaysia to cut their household budgets. Besides that, the cheaper products that come from China will encourage local industrial players to improve their products and win the market back. In other words, the cheaper products will create a healthy competition in the Malaysian market. Moreover, local industrial players cannot always rely on government help in facing the competition from China. Dr. Hummels said, “Such policies like protecting firms, setting up quotas and tariffs are generally disastrous for a country’s economy.” What the government can do to help them is just to provide the best infrastructure and set up competition-promoting policies. This same idea is promoted by Peter J Llyod in his article, “A Competition Policy For Malaysia”. According to him, the main objective of the policy is to create better competitive environment in Malaysia’s economy and the policy should be comprehensive, promote competition and run by an independent agency.
Last but not least, Malaysia can also take advantage of extensive trade between China and European countries as it is located on the strategic way main way between China and Europe. In fact, the Malacca strait on the west of peninsular Malaysia is the busiest strait in the world and receives the highest number of ships annually. Malaysia has taken a step forward by establishing several ports along the coast of peninsular Malaysia like Tanjung Pelepas Port and Pasir Gudang Port. These ports are specially built to be a transshipment hub on the major shipping route of the world. There, ships that come from China or from the European continent can exchange their products with local products or having maintenance operation after long journey.
Despite the advantages discussed earlier, we should realize that trade with China still has some negative impacts on Malaysia like the waning of foreign direct investment (FDI) in Malaysia. Even though Malaysia records a high FDI every year, the numbers actually have declined in recent years. Moreover, Malaysia’s neighbor, Indonesia has overtaken Malaysia in terms of the FDI and not to mention China, which is the world’s top recipient of FDI. This proves that Malaysia has lost its competitiveness with China and has failed to attract international entrepreneurs to set up their businesses there. Therefore, the Malaysian government should deal with this issue seriously and should not be complacent with the fact that Malaysia always scores billions of FDI annually.
Trade with China should be perceived in positive ways as it will provide more opportunities for Malaysian entrepreneurs to extend their business abroad. It also enables Malaysia to export its high-skilled labor and natural resources to China. Moreover, trade with China will benefit Malaysian consumers as they will have cheaper goods from China in the market. Malaysia also can be a transshipment hub as it located in major route between China and the west. Even though Malaysia lost its attraction among foreign investors as they prefer to go to China, Malaysia still can win foreign investors if it emulates China’s actions like setting up special economic zones that provide the best infrastructures and economic system for investors. Therefore, Malaysians should realize that trade with China give more opportunities for them in economy.